FOS, there is no one opinion here. And multiplicity of opinions is good.
But don't take it too personally that some people would say these things -- it's only their opinion, and they are entitled to their beliefs without benefit of competition or debate.
I personally like Jake's acting a lot, but I don't think this should stand in the way of other people appreciating other roles and other actors. We all have favorite artists who we consider to be good/great. That is natural -- and wonderful.