Topic: What did Ennis or Jack say in the first tent scene? (Spoiler)

[matsuki33]

Well when i saw the movie i heard something like What are you doing he said it twice before jack start taking off his pants

[ethan]

"what are you doing" is also what I heard.

[sam]

I heard (too!):

First scene: Ennis (bewilderd & still groggy from sleep & drink):"What ya doin'?"

Second scene:(Ennis whispering to Jack twice, VERY softly:) "I'm sorry"
                     "I'm sorry" (This is barely audible...but, perk up your ears and watch/read his lips and you will see!)
                     Jack: "It's all right..."

me thinks: Ennis is:
1- sorry for being so 'cool' to Jack the following morning while getting his horse ready,  after that first night in the tent together...
2- sorry for being so silent about the whole situation...not giving-in to his true feelings...not accepting Jacks 'warmth'...denying the fact...
3- sorry for saying: "It's  a one shot thing we got goin' on here"...while knowing that he wants more...
4- sorry for implying that Jack is a queer (in the previous scene...) Jack: "You know I ain't queer.  Me neither."...
5- sorry now, for not crawling into the tent on the second night along with Jack...making Jack wait alone in the tent for him...while he sits outside next to the fire...(Jack still not knowing if Ennis will follow him into the tent...)

me thinks: Jack says: "It's all right..."
In which he means:...I understand how hard (and new) it is for you...come here...it's all right...I understand how difficult it is...you're forgiven...it's all right Ennis...

sam

[justlikethisalways]

Listening to it right now... (recorded it in the theater)

1st tent scene: Ennis mumbles once, "What are you doing?" (all slurred together so it sounds more like "Wha'doin'?) Even though these are the only words in this scene, there's still a lot of "communication" going on! 

2nd tent scene: I love the idea of Ennis saying "I'm sorry" -- it would add so much to this scene, but I only hear Jack saying "It's all right" three times (which also agrees with the screenplay). But, that's just my opinion... 

[anne]

I think Ennis doesn't say anything. Jack says tree times "that's allright", or two times "I'm sorry" and then "that's allright". 

[anne]

Oh, I have subtittles...




00:33:36,480 --> 00:33:37,780
It's all right

236
00:33:40,580 --> 00:33:41,880
It's all right

237
00:33:42,910 --> 00:33:44,780
Lie back. Come on




I can't hear the third one, but maybe he says so...   


I can't watch this movie again... I don't understand what is happening with me... I just can't stop thinking about them and this 4 days I live  with this movie and pics, and trailers and soundtracks...
What can I do... :\'( :\'(

This is the greatest love story.

Somebody 

HELP

[/b]

[ennie]

others said they might of hear something like f*** me or smth